Cosmic Typing Bug: Doom Desire Damage Calculation?

by Admin 51 views
Cosmic Typing Issue with Doom Desire

Hey guys! Let's dive into a peculiar issue spotted in TheTrainerCorner regarding Cosmic typing and the move Doom Desire. There seems to be a discrepancy in how damage is calculated, specifically when Cosmic-typed Pokémon are involved.

The Initial Observation

In a replay from the gen9nationaldexspeedtour, it was noted that a Doom Desire (Cosmic) transformed into Octolure should have taken super effective damage. However, the expected damage calculation didn't seem to pan out. Here’s the crucial turn in question:

The core of the issue lies in how Cosmic typing interacts with other types, especially when it comes to dealing and receiving damage. According to the Readjustment project's Cosmic Chart, the following rules apply:

Cosmic Offense

When a Cosmic-type Pokémon uses a move:

  • Deals Super Effective damage to: Fire, Water & Cosmic types.
  • Deals Not Very Effective damage to: Ice, Bug, & Dark types.
  • Poison types are Immune to Cosmic moves.

Cosmic Defense

When a Cosmic-type Pokémon is on the receiving end:

  • Takes Super Effective damage from: Ice, Poison, Bug & Cosmic types.
  • Takes Not Very Effective damage from: Electric, Fighting, Ground & Dark types.
  • Fire moves Cannot Hit Cosmic types.

Given these rules, Octolure, after being transformed into a Cosmic type, should have taken super effective damage from another Cosmic-type move like Doom Desire. But that’s not what happened, leading us to question whether the typing chart is being correctly applied in the game.

Possible Causes

So, what could be the reason behind this unexpected outcome? Here are a few possibilities:

Incorrect Type Interaction

It's possible that the game isn't correctly recognizing the type interactions between Cosmic and other types. This could be a bug in the damage calculation formula or an issue with how the types are defined in the game's code. The Readjustment project's typing might not be perfectly synced with the actual mechanics implemented in TheTrainerCorner.

Doom Desire Glitch

There's also a chance that Doom Desire itself has a glitch. The report mentions that in a separate test match, Doom Desire only dealt 10% of the target's HP. If this is the case, the problem might not be with Cosmic typing in general, but rather with how Doom Desire is implemented. Maybe the move isn't correctly applying the type matchups or has a fixed damage output regardless of effectiveness.

Transformation Quirks

Transformations can sometimes lead to unexpected behavior in Pokémon battles. When a Pokémon transforms into a Cosmic type, there might be issues with how the game updates its type matchups or vulnerabilities. It's possible that the transformation process isn't correctly applying the Cosmic typing, leading to incorrect damage calculations.

Display Error

Although less likely, there could be a display error. The damage might have been calculated correctly, but the displayed value could be wrong. This would mean the underlying mechanics are working as intended, but the user interface is showing incorrect information.

Community Insights and Further Testing

To get to the bottom of this, we need more testing and community input. Have any of you guys experienced similar issues with Cosmic typing or Doom Desire? Sharing your experiences and replays could help us identify patterns and narrow down the cause of the bug.

Replicating the Scenario

One of the best ways to confirm the bug is to replicate the scenario in a controlled environment. Set up a battle with Cosmic-type Pokémon using Doom Desire and observe the damage output. Vary the target's type and defensive stats to see if the damage calculation aligns with the expected type matchups.

Analyzing Replays

Analyzing more replays that involve Cosmic-type Pokémon and Doom Desire can provide valuable insights. Look for instances where the damage output seems inconsistent with the type matchups. Pay attention to any unique conditions or abilities that might be influencing the outcome.

Checking the Code

If possible, examining the game's code could reveal the underlying cause of the bug. Look for the damage calculation formula and how it handles Cosmic typing. Check for any conditional statements or special cases that might be affecting the damage output of Doom Desire.

The Importance of Accurate Type Matchups

Accurate type matchups are essential for fair and balanced gameplay. When type interactions are inconsistent or buggy, it can lead to confusion, frustration, and a loss of competitive integrity. That’s why it’s crucial to identify and fix any issues with Cosmic typing or Doom Desire as soon as possible.

Competitive Balance

In competitive Pokémon, type matchups are a fundamental aspect of strategy. Players rely on their knowledge of type interactions to make informed decisions about which moves to use and which Pokémon to bring to battle. When type matchups are inconsistent, it can disrupt the competitive balance and make it difficult for players to strategize effectively.

Player Experience

Inconsistent type matchups can also negatively impact the player experience. When moves don't deal the expected amount of damage, it can lead to confusion and frustration. Players might lose battles they should have won, or vice versa, which can be demoralizing. Accurate type matchups are essential for providing a fair and enjoyable gaming experience.

Game Integrity

Finally, accurate type matchups are crucial for maintaining the integrity of the game. When type interactions are buggy or inconsistent, it can create loopholes and exploits that can be abused by unscrupulous players. This can undermine the fairness of the game and damage its reputation.

Conclusion

The Cosmic typing issue with Doom Desire raises significant questions about the accuracy of type matchups in TheTrainerCorner. Whether it's a bug in the damage calculation formula, a glitch with Doom Desire, or an issue with transformations, it's essential to investigate and resolve the problem to ensure fair and balanced gameplay. Let's work together to gather more information, conduct further testing, and get to the bottom of this Cosmic mystery! Keep battling, keep testing, and let's make sure everything is working as it should. Peace out, trainers!